Salim Khan and Javed Akhtar are revered names in Hindi cinema. They’ve given Bollywood some of its most iconic films, from “Sholay” to “Zanjeer.” However, recent claims by writer Amit Aaryan have cast a shadow over their legacy. Aaryan, known for his work on the popular TV show “FIR,” made headlines when he labeled Salim and Javed not as writers, but as copywriters. This controversial statement has sparked debates across the film industry and among fans of the legendary duo.
Amit Aaryan’s Bold Claim
In an interview with Digital Commentary, Amit Aaryan did not hold back his opinion on Salim-Javed. He stated, “I do not even consider Salim-Javed to be a writer. They are only copywriters, not original creators.” His argument centered around the notion that many of their most famous works, including the blockbuster “Sholay,” were copied or heavily inspired by earlier films.
Aaryan cited the example of the 1971 film “Mera Gaon Mera Desh,” in which Vinod Khanna played a dacoit named Jabbar Singh. According to him, this character directly inspired the infamous Gabbar Singh in “Sholay.” He also pointed out that both films feature a protagonist seeking revenge after losing a hand, drawing parallels between the plots. Aaryan’s accusations did not stop there. He also alleged that other Salim-Javed classics, such as “Deewar,” were similarly derived from older films like Dilip Kumar’s “Ganga Jamuna.”
The Debate over Originality in Bollywood
Aaryan’s statements have reignited the age-old debate about originality in Bollywood. In an industry that thrives on remakes and adaptations, the question of what constitutes “copying” versus “inspiration” is a fine line. Salim-Javed’s fans argue that while their films may have drawn from existing stories, they redefined these narratives in ways that made them uniquely theirs. On the other hand, critics like Aaryan claim that this reworking amounts to little more than clever repackaging.
The duo’s creative process has long been the subject of fascination. Known for their collaborative writing sessions, Salim and Javed were credited with transforming the hero-centric narrative of Bollywood by introducing anti-heroes and complex villains. Their films not only entertained but also reflected the socio-political atmosphere of the time, especially during the 1970s when India was grappling with significant economic and social challenges.
Salim and Javed’s Response
While Salim Khan and Javed Akhtar have remained largely silent on Aaryan’s allegations, their body of work speaks volumes. The duo is celebrated not just for their commercial success but for their lasting influence on Bollywood storytelling. Films like “Sholay,” “Deewar,” and “Don” are still considered benchmarks for writing in Indian cinema, with their dialogues and characters becoming cultural phenomena.
The recent docuseries “Angry Young Men,” streaming on Prime Video, explores the legacy of Salim-Javed in great detail. Directed by Namrata Rao, the series sheds light on how the duo revolutionized Hindi cinema. It also delves into their eventual split in 1982, a moment that became a national topic of discussion. Through this series, the duo’s fans are reminded of their immense contributions, while critics are given more context to understand their creative journey.
The Verdict: Are Salim-Javed Copywriters or Geniuses?
Amit Aaryan’s claims may have stirred up controversy, but they are unlikely to diminish the status of Salim and Javed as icons of Indian cinema. Their influence on Bollywood is undeniable, and while there may be truth in the idea that they borrowed from other works, it is equally true that they reshaped these narratives in groundbreaking ways.
As Bollywood continues to evolve, the question of originality will remain a constant. However, in the case of Salim-Javed, their lasting legacy is not just in the stories they told, but in the way they told them. They brought a new depth to Bollywood scripts, forever changing the landscape of Indian cinema.
In the ongoing debate between creativity and originality, Salim Khan and Javed Akhtar stand as towering figures. Amit Aaryan’s claims of plagiarism may spark conversations, but they cannot erase the duo’s monumental contributions to Bollywood. Whether one views them as copywriters or creative geniuses, one thing is clear: Salim-Javed will forever remain a legend in Indian cinema.
